But Why Do We Have to Learn Spanish?
Inside: Why learn Spanish? Why learn a second language at all?
As I prepare for the beginning of a new school year, I know this question will come up at some point. Though the tone of voice that goes with that sort of whyyy is not my favorite, it’s a valid question. Why are we here? Why are we learning Spanish? Why do we have to learn a foreign language at all?
It’s something I ask myself, here and there. I thought about it today, a long tired day. By the end my brain was mush, and I could just hear the mistakes coming out, talking with my little ones at home. Is this worth it, really? Is it worth the extra tiredness, me stumbling here as I talk to a three-year-old?
When I look at my fresh-faced Spanish I class, I know what I’d like to say. I want to tell them, “This is magic.” It is magic, and life-altering. But of course I cannot say that. Even if I did, you can’t say something is magic anymore than you can tell someone chocolate cake is delicious. They must of course find out for themselves.
I think I killed the magic my first few years of teaching. We enjoyed each other, had fun, and did our best as we waded through the building blocks of pieces of grammar and vocabulary. But I started with the parts: the difficult, unwieldy rules of language, with all their exceptions and requirements. By the time we got to the beauty of it– the real stories and songs and people–many of my students had checked out. Perhaps they passed the tests. But Spanish had not become a part of them, the way things we love do.
So what do we say, these first few weeks? Why are we here, after all? I used to show a little PowerPoint on the first day of class. It spoke of the benefits of learning a second language, in the most pragmatic ways. By learning Spanish you can get better jobs, I told them. You can make more money. Your brain gets stronger and most resistant to Alzheimer’s. You can travel!
Most of those are perfectly good perks to learning a language, especially the traveling part. But what I wish I could make them understand is what a second language does for your soul. When I say travel, I’m not just picturing a fun vacation. I am thinking of the sort of travel that changes you. Even every Disney movie knows that money and success aren’t what drive us. We are at school, sitting in Spanish class, because it makes us a different sort of person. I am speaking Spanish to my kids because I think it will help them be wiser and kinder. The hope is that we grow in wisdom and virtue, that we acquire more empathy, more compassion, more concern for the world. The hope is that we become employers concerned about more than the bottom line, neighbors befriending the family down the street, and people who see that ours is not the only way.
This year, I’m not presenting a defense of Spanish the first day of class. I am not sure that anyone remembers anything from the first day, anyway, except how it felt. I’m saving it for a bit later, when we’ve had the chance for a story or two and music. Then we can ask, Why are we here?, and perhaps have something to say.
Join the newsletter
Want to stay in touch and hear from me weekly?
Sign up now and you'll get this free game set.
I LOVE this post! I’m a first-year teacher, and at this point in the year (7 weeks left to the 20-week Spring Semester), I just switched to reading a storybook because my students were bogged down by the grammar and “building blocks” as you beautifully worded it. Their confidence was also low, so the book seems to be having a good turnaround on their mentality.
I thought I’d share a video I found on the second day of school and showed to my students. It captures the “language of experience”, the kind of language that brings people together. I explained that, in sharing experiences in a person’s native language, you’re building immeasurably stronger connections with them and making them feel more “alive” as they share their story.
I also shared with them early on in the year that, when I was in middle and high school, I was “eh” about Spanish. I even stopped my senior year because AP Spanish had me crying every day at lunch (not the best way to spend your senior year). I found my love for it when I picked it back up in college (when I was still “eh” about the language).
These two things truly brought me closer to my students. I hope you enjoy the video!
Beautifully written! Thank you!